Lumpectomy Vs. Mastectomy: How to Decide? The Pros & Cons of Lumpectomy & Mastectomy After Breast Cancer Diagnosis by Dr. Constance Chen

Women's Health Cancer
2 years ago

Lumpectomy Vs. Mastectomy: How to Decide? The Pros & Cons of Lumpectomy & Mastectomy After Breast Cancer Diagnosis

While coping with the emotional turmoil that follows a breast cancer diagnosis, a woman must absorb a seemingly vast amount of information that will help her make important decisions about the treatment options available to her. Many women with early-stage cancer learn that while surgery will be needed, the decision of whether to attempt to remove just the tumor or the whole affected breast will be up to her.

Women are often puzzled that there isn't a clear medical imperative that dictates which surgery she should have. Her doctor will explain that given the characteristics of her particular tumor, the risk of her cancer recurring is low and her odds of survival are the same whether she undergoes mastectomy, which removes the entire breast, or lumpectomy, which attempts to remove only the tumor and conserve the breast. She can weigh the factors that go into this decision with confidence that either choice will enhance her chances of a full recovery.

In the 18th century, breast cancer came to be understood as a localized disease whose spread could be contained by isolating and removing the affected cells, thus giving rise to what we know today as mastectomy. The radical mastectomy was first performed in the late 1800s, removing not just the breast tissue and adjacent lymph nodes but the underlying chest muscles as well in an aggressive attempt to control the spread of the disease. It was not until the mid-20th century that radical surgery gave way to equally effective but less aggressive, less disfiguring treatments and not until the 1980s that research showed that lumpectomy followed by a course of radiation treatment provided statistically equivalent survival rates as mastectomy.

As we came to understand that survival rates are similar for mastectomy and lumpectomy, many women chose the less invasive, breast-conserving lumpectomy, but in the last two decades or so, influenced by public discussion of celebrities' mastectomies and by advances in breast reconstruction that have made it possible to create a new breast barely distinguishable from a woman's own, more women have turned again to mastectomy as the treatment that will work best for them.

Lumpectomy: Advantages and Disadvantages

Lumpectomy, also known as “breast-conserving surgery,” attempts to remove all the breast tissue affected by cancer as well as a small surrounding margin of normal tissue. A lumpectomy is almost always followed by a five- to seven-week course of daily radiation therapy to reduce the risk of local recurrence in the breast.

The primary advantage of lumpectomy is that it can preserve the breast and often with minimal change in sensation. It is a less invasive surgery, often performed on an out-patient basis or with a one-night hospital stay, so recovery is faster and easier. In addition, for women with larger breasts, the appearance of the breast may also be largely preserved.

Disadvantages of lumpectomy may include the all-but-certain need for post-operative radiation therapy that has some side effects and requires daily trips to the treatment facility. Radiation may limit later options to achieve symmetry with the untreated breast as it permanently changes and distorts the tissue. Also, women with smaller breasts may be left with a very deformed appearance to their remaining breast.

Further surgery may be necessary following a lumpectomy: If the pathology report shows cancer cells at the edge of the excised tissue, the lack of “clear margins” means additional tissue will have to be removed to try to ensure no remaining cancer cells. The additional excision may cause further disfigurement or, in some cases, mastectomy might be needed.

It is important to note that while the survival rates are considered statistically equivalent for lumpectomy and mastectomy, there is a slightly higher risk with lumpectomy of local recurrence of cancer in the treated breast. These recurrences can often be successfully treated, usually with mastectomy.

Mastectomy: Advantages and Disadvantages

For some women, even the low risk of recurrence in the breast following lumpectomy is enough for them to want to “just be rid of it,” to remove as much breast tissue as possible. For these women, mastectomy with or without reconstruction is their best option for peace of mind.

The most significant disadvantage of mastectomy is the permanent loss of the breast. A simple mastectomy with no reconstruction can be an outpatient procedure with recovery time similar to a lumpectomy. This is even true for nipple-sparing mastectomy with no reconstruction, which preserves all options for the best possible breast reconstruction later on. If immediate breast reconstruction is added, mastectomy is a more complex surgery with a longer recuperation and with the possibility of additional surgery needed in association with reconstruction; even if the initial reconstruction is performed at the time of the mastectomy, adjustments are often needed later.

There are many factors that influence the selection of treatment options for early-stage breast cancer. Your doctor will have carefully studied the size, location and characteristics of your tumor as well as your general medical and genetic history before reaching the conclusion that you can safely make the decision of lumpectomy or mastectomy based on personal considerations. If it is up to you, you will weigh questions like: How important is it to you to keep your breast? How anxious will you be about recurrence and annual screenings if you do keep your breast? How important are factors like surgical recuperation and daily radiation therapy? Your doctor, family, and friends may provide counsel and support but by weighing what is most important to you, you will come to the best decision for your health and for a cancer-free future.

The content on is for informational and entertainment purposes only, and should not be considered medical advice. The information on this site should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease, and is not a substitute for professional care. Always consult your personal healthcare provider. The opinions or views expressed on do not necessarily represent those of 30Seconds or any of its employees, corporate partners or affiliates.

Take 30 seconds and join the 30Seconds community, and follow us on Facebook to get inspiration in your newsfeed daily. Inspire and be inspired.

Related Products on Amazon We Think You May Like:

30Second Mobile, Inc. is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

Breast Cancer Facts: 5 Things About Breast Cancer You May Not Know

Preventative Mastectomy: The Procedure's Rates Are on the Rise, But Why?

​Nipple-sparing Mastectomy: Choosing the Right Breast Surgeon & Getting the Best Reconstruction Outcome

A Blueprint to Help Beat Breast Cancer From the American Institute for Cancer Research

Elisa Schmitz
Really helpful information here, Dr. Constance Chen . With so many women having to face this decision, it is incredibly appreciated, thank you.
Several friends are going through this 🙏🏼
Sorry this decision needs to be made, by so many women.
I know someone going through this right now. Thank you for posting this. It helped clear up a lot of questions I had. That I would not feel comfortable asking her. Luv & light.

join discussion

Please login to comment.

recommended tips

Try Yoga for Strength, Flexibility & Relaxation! My Favorite Pose Is...

Simple Yoga Poses: How to Get Your Downward Dog On!

Yoga Poses: Work on Your Balance & Strength With Tree Pose!

Yoga Poses That Tone Your Abs & Tush: Plank Your Way to a Stronger Core!