Do Time-Outs Need a Time-Out? Some Thoughts on Disciplining Kids! by Ann Marie Gardinier Halstead

Parenting
a year ago
Do Time-Outs Need a Time-Out? Some Thoughts on Disciplining Kids!

Psychologist Montrose M. Wolf developed the “time-out” technique as a learning tool to shape kids’ behavior in the 1960s, and the technique has become popular since then. However, according to Dr. Mary C. Lamia, “In using time-outs parents unintentionally convey that they are unable to contain their own feelings and cannot tolerate their own negative response … to the child’s behavior.” Dr. Lamia asserts that:

  • Psychologically, kids may respond just as poorly to a time-out as they would to physical punishment due to the rejection and social isolation, which are experienced as shame. 
  • Shaming experiences lead children to believe their entire self is bad, rather than just their behavior. 
  • Discipline is different than punishment. Time-outs are a punishment.

Great food for thought! What do you think? Read more about time-outs and kids here!

start discussion

Please login to comment.

recommended tips

Disciplining Kids: 5 Steps to Help Parents & Babysitters Get on the Same Page!

A Note to My Teenage Daughters: You Are Too Old for Me to Babysit!

Planning a Road Trip Is the Perfect Opportunity to Teach Kids Real-Life Geography & Math Skills

Discipline Techniques: It's Time to Put "Time-Out" in Time-Out – Try This Instead!

Got 30 seconds? Sign up for 30Seconds.com and get the best of our tips each week!